Is ‘Eating Clean’ Really So Healthy?

by in Shades Of Blue, Wellbeing

I will need to address this topic over a series of articles, but in this post, I’m going to provide you with a fluff-free overview of why I HATE the term ‘eating clean’.

Firstly, before the abuse starts streaming in, I appreciate there are those people who genuinely love to adhere to 100% natural, unprocessed, organic diet and have gladly adapted their lifestyle to accommodate it. If you’re one of this minority, good for you! There’s no denying this is a very healthy existence, IF you genuinely enjoy it and your primary motivations for eating that way are health- and longevity-based.

Secondly, healthy eating is of course something I promote and encourage wholeheartedly – I am not in any way suggesting that said natural, unprocessed, organic foods are bad. That would be silly. No, it’s the term ‘clean’ that I take issue with.

I can’t stand it when a specific, rigid way of eating is preached as the best and only way of eating; the unnecessary pressure this puts on those for whom this level of inflexibility is unrealistic; when it’s viewed as inadequate, undedicated, if one’s fridge contents aren’t entirely organic, grass-fed, raw, or whatever else the fanaticism of the moment requires. Privately educated and lovingly reared by unicorns. The list is ever-growing.

I digress…

Define ‘Clean’?

First of all, let’s address the term itself. ‘Clean’. What does this actually mean? It would seem the answer to that depends wholly on who you ask. Some will say a ‘clean’ diet is one that’s based around wholesome, natural foods. Others consider dairy a ‘dirty’ food, despite it fitting the aforementioned criteria, or include protein powder as a ‘clean’ food, despite it usually being full of chemicals. Some view wholegrains as ‘clean’, whilst others perceive them as an abomination against the diet of our caveman forefathers. Often, a ‘clean’ diet incorporates a weekly ‘cheat meal’, or as the common man may refer to it, a weekly junk food binge. ‘Clean’ is dubious, often contrived to mean whatever the dieter wants it to mean at the time and will never have a universally agreed definition.

Stress

One of my biggest gripes with restrictive diets is the level of stress they generate for (most) people. The hormonal and psychological response to consistent, high levels of stress is the antithesis of fitness and wellbeing. I’m not going to venture into the impact of prolonged cortisol elevation here, but I will address this in a later article. In short, it’s going to screw up both your health and physique goals to a far greater extent than affording yourself the occasional Hobnob.

Extreme Comparisons

At one end of the spectrum, you have those who will only eat unprocessed, organic foods, along with a selection of other ‘rules’ – the more challenging to adhere to the better.  Anything that flouts the rules is described as ‘cheating’. The opposite extreme are those completely unaware of what they put into their mouths and, frankly, don’t really care – anything goes. Often, the obsessively ‘clean’ dieter will try to rationalise by comparing these extremes like they’re the only two options available. “Oh right, so I should forgo the broccoli and have a doughnut then?” There is a flagrant denial of any sort of healthy middle-ground.

Disordered Eating Behaviour

Let’s list some examples of the behaviour obsessive ‘clean’ eating can encourage:

+ Labelling foods as ‘good’ and ‘bad’ (or ‘clean’ and ‘cheating’)
+ Scheduled ‘cheat’ meals leading to binges
+ Compensating for the binges with excessive exercise
+ Having a guilt complex around food
+ Cutting out entire food groups
+ Having a rigid set of rules around food
+ Avoiding social situations that could interfere with these rules
+ Extreme anxiety when anything happens that could interfere with these rules

These don’t necessarily add up to an eating disorder but they can easily go that way. Take it from someone who lost most of her teenage years to anorexia – once you develop that mind-set, it’s incredibly difficult to re-establish a healthy relationship with food. I’ll leave it at that – this is something else that requires its own dedicated article.

In summary…

The ‘perfect diet’ is personal – it depends on a variety of physiological, hormonal, activity and lifestyle factors and it changes as these factors change for the individual. There are no fundamentally ‘good’ or ‘bad’ foods (except for maybe trans fats, but again, one for another post!), just a good diet plan or a bad diet plan. A diet of mostly nutrition-void junk food choices is a bad diet plan. A diet rigidly based around someone’s definition of ‘clean’ could also be a bad diet plan, IF that ‘clean’ diet is having a detrimental impact psychologically and hormonally.

A starting point for establishing a good diet plan is to find a comfortable place somewhere in the middle of these extremes and to think of your eating as being ‘on plan’ or ‘off plan’, rather than ‘clean’ or ‘cheating’.

40 replies on “Is ‘Eating Clean’ Really So Healthy?“

  • pcassidy_CI

    TrainWithCharli good article. Point about protein particularly pertinent: some consume 2 much + put kidneys under strain – stones or worse

  • Ri026

    nice blogs….i was confused with the term of clean eating…now u just explained all in one page!! thaaannnkkk youuu 🙂

  • KDFitPro

    TrainWithCharli this really described my current relationship with food. Thank you for this! Im trying to relax my rules atm #hardwork

  • TrainWithCharli

    TrainWithCharli this really described my current relationship with food. Thank you for this! Im trying to relax my rules atm #hardwork

  • TheErgDaddy

    TrainWithCharli great blog post! You can see examples everywhere on twitter of the behaviours you list!

  • TrainWithCharli

    KDFitPro Great to hear you’re already addressing this and seeking more balance, Kate! I know how scary it can be to relax on rules x

  • TrainWithCharli

    TrainWithCharli great blog post! You can see examples everywhere on twitter of the behaviours you list!

  • KDFitPro

    TrainWithCharli but the hard work pays off! Ive learnt that through my battles. If u get chance to read my blog you will understand x

  • TrainWithCharli

    TrainWithCharli but the hard work pays off! Ive learnt that through my battles. If u get chance to read my blog you will understand x

  • TrainWithCharli

    KDFitPro I actually started reading your blog last week and can relate a great deal. You’re doing fantastically well x

  • TrainWithCharli

    KDFitPro I actually started reading your blog last week and can relate a great deal. You’re doing fantastically well x

  • sammipunk

    TrainWithCharli I’m glad you said some of the things I’ve been thinking! Looking forward to future blogs on the topic! 🙂

  • KDFitPro

    TrainWithCharli thank you, it’s inspiring to see someone like youself doing so well after being through similar #StrongWoman x

  • TrainWithCharli

    KDFitPro I’m much stronger for having battled through it though – I wouldn’t be doing what I do today had it not been for that experience x

  • KDFitPro

    TrainWithCharli my thoughts exactly. Not the nicest way to learn how to fight but makes everything else seem easier to battle x

  • SarahP_Fitness

    TrainWithCharli great post!So refreshing to hear some realistic good advice from a PT see so many promoting clean eating its impossible! Xx

  • TrainWithCharli

    SarahP_Fitness Thanks Sarah! It’s so frustrating to see the pressure and stress it generates. Xx

  • stokiesaint

    TrainWithCharli Good point on the definition. For me “Clean” is purely about avoiding overly processed, chemical laden foods/drinks.

  • TrainWithCharli

    thesbcollective Thanks! It felt good to get it out of my system and into the blogosphere x

  • LBehrG

    TrainWithCharli diets are so personal & individual. I lost 7 stone 9 yrs ago but what worked for me wouldn’t necessary work for others

  • TrainWithCharli

    TrainWithCharli diets are so personal & individual. I lost 7 stone 9 yrs ago but what worked for me wouldn’t necessary work for others

  • LBehrG

    TrainWithCharli also preaching and being evangelical about something just as likely to put people off 🙂

  • Breanna_Coates

    “TrainWithCharli: #ImTiredOfHearing #eatclean – but before you get upset with me, here’s why” hm you must think vegans are crazy..??

  • TrainWithCharli

    Breanna_Coates It suits some people. My concern is those forcing themselves into lifestyles they don’t want because they think it’s ‘best’.

  • sara_foodiary

    TrainWithCharli So true that ‘clean eating’ although very good, puts a lot of pressure on us to be ‘perfect’ all of the time. x

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.